By Carl I. S. Mueller, Partner, Mueller Christensen LLP
When a representation ends, a request for “the file” usually follows. For many, there is a reflex, either to box everything up and send it or give the client only filed documents and discovery. Those reflexes are understandable and sometimes are the right call. But more or less may be required, there’s a gray area, and the details matter.
What the Rules of Professional Conduct require
Rule 1.16(e)(1) of the California Rules of Professional Conduct requires a lawyer, on request, to promptly release “client materials and property” at the end of a representation, whether or not the client has paid. The rule lists correspondence, pleadings, deposition transcripts, exhibits, physical evidence, reports from retained witnesses, and other items reasonably necessary to the client’s representation. Rule 1.16(d) adds the broader duty to avoid reasonably foreseeable prejudice to the client’s rights. (See also State Bar Formal Opn. No. 2020-201.)
The list is notable for what it does not say. It does not mention a lawyer’s internal analysis by name.
The statute protects the lawyer’s thinking
Code of Civil Procedure section 2018.030 divides work product into two categories. A writing that reflects an attorney’s impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal research or theories is protected absolutely. Other work product is protected conditionally. Lasky, Haas, Cohler & Munter v. Superior Court (1985) 172 Cal.App.3d 264 is generally read to treat the attorney, not the client, as the holder of that protection, with the duty to release turning on whether withholding would prejudice the former client.
Other authority points the other way
Older decisions, including Kallen v. Delug (1984) 157 Cal.App.3d 940 and Weiss v. Marcus (1975) 51 Cal.App.3d 590, contain language that an attorney’s work product belongs to the client. Ethics authorities have also tended to frame the question around foreseeable prejudice. The San Francisco Bar Association, for example, has taken the position that uncommunicated work product should be released where failing to do so would result in reasonably foreseeable prejudice to the client’s rights (S.F. Bar Assn. Ethics Opn. 1990-1).
Put together, the answer is not a bright line. Client materials, meaning those provided by the client, almost always go back to the client. However, internal analysis may be withheld, unless successor counsel needs it to protect the client. What counts as “reasonably foreseeable prejudice” is where the argument lives, and reasonable lawyers read the cases differently.
Timing matters
Code of Civil Procedure section 2018.080 provides that there is no work product privilege in an action between an attorney and a client or former client if the material is relevant to an issue of the attorney’s breach of a duty arising from the relationship. By its terms the exception applies only in such an action. Until one is filed, the statute is not triggered, and the lawyer may arguably continue to assert the protection.
That is not the end of the analysis. If a malpractice or fee action follows, the same material may become reachable. A decision made as to work product at termination of the attorney-client relationship is therefore one a lawyer should be prepared to explain later.
Practical points
- Sort before responding. Separate client materials, the items Rule 1.16(e) lists, from internal analysis such as research memoranda, strategy notes, and draft theories.
- Do not let an unpaid invoice drive the answer. The release obligation does not depend on payment.
- Ask what successor counsel needs and by when. Pending deadlines, limitation periods, and scheduled hearings are where the prejudice question is decided.
- Record what was released, what was held, and why. Assume the file may someday be read by someone adverse.
- Ask for advice. If in doubt, seek advice from ethics counsel, whether your firm’s internal general counsel or outside counsel (many insurance policies allow advising services).
As always, educate yourself: the relevant case law is very fact specific, and the cases do not all point in the same direction. When a request for a file arrives alongside a fee dispute or a potential claim, a short call before the response goes out is usually worth it.
This article is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.